Math Therapy
Math Therapy explores the root causes of math trauma, and the empowering ways we can heal from it. Each week host Vanessa Vakharia, aka The Math Guru, dives into what we get right and wrong about math education, and chats with some of today’s most inspiring and visionary minds working to make math more accessible, diverse, and fun for students of all ages. Whether you think you’re a "math person" or not, you’re about to find out that math people don’t actually exist – but the scars that math class left on many of us, definitely do. And don’t worry, no calculators or actual math were involved in the making of this podcast ;)
Math Therapy
What happens when teachers aren't allowed to trust their instincts? w/ Trista Matthews
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Send us a text! (US messaging rates apply)
What happens when teachers are told to follow the curriculum EXACTLY, even when they know their students need something different? At what point does following the rules actually get in the way of the art of good teaching?!
Vanessa met Trista Matthews at the Cotsen Foundation's annual conference in California, and just HOURS later they were recording this completely unplanned conversation! Trista is a veteran elementary educator and mentor coach who's helping teachers navigate the increasingly complicated tension between curriculum expectations and their own professional judgment. And she has some BIG thoughts about what it really means to teach with "fidelity".
They discuss:
- Why teaching with fidelity may be impossible when teaching is a human art form
- How scripted curricula can leave teachers feeling powerless, frustrated, and unseen
- What teachers can actually do to protect their creativity and advocate for their students
This conversation is a reminder that teachers aren't robots, students aren't identical, and good teaching can't always follow a script. But finding a balance between consistency and creativity isn't simple - we'd LOVE to hear what you think so text us if you have any ideas!
Links mentioned:
- Episode: How to get fired up about teaching (even if the system has crushed your spirit) w/ Chase Orton
- Episode: How to follow the curriculum without selling your soul
- Resource: Free Math Therapy Toolkit — including math mindset surveys
About Trista:
Trista Matthews is an elementary educator and mentor coach in Orange County, California. As a mentor with the Cotsen Foundation for the Art of Teaching, she supports fellow teachers through ongoing coaching, professional development, and collaborative inquiry. Passionate about teacher creativity, student-centered learning, and building positive math identities, Trista advocates for giving educators the trust, support, and freedom they need to respond to the students in front of them.
Contact us:
- Vanessa Vakharia: Instagram, TikTok, Email
- Math Therapy: Text the Podcast
More Math Therapy:
Trista Matthews
Trista Matthewsand even me, I mean, I'm guilty of it. Before I knew, I would be like, "Oh, my district said I have to do this to fidelity. That's what I need to do." But, like, I didn't even know what I was saying. there's never anything that can be done with fidelity, if we're talking about a human connection and a human experience as teaching.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay, guys. Welcome back to Math Therapy, and today, against my better judgment, we are wading into the very murky waters of one of the hottest debates in math education right now. So I'm just gonna rip the Band-Aid off and give you one question to ponder: If we don't want our students to be robots, why would we ask our teachers to teach like robots? Now, look, I'm not an expert in curriculum, and I'm still trying to figure out how I even feel about this debate, but here's what I do know. So many teachers, students, and parents that I talk to every day feel pulled in two opposing directions. We want kids to think creatively, take risks, and develop their own strategies, and we want teachers to feel empowered to support each student however they can. But on the other hand, many teachers are being asked to, like, follow highly prescribed curricula designed to ensure that every student gets access to high-quality instruction, no matter who's teaching them. But what happens when following the script means ignoring what you know your own unique students actually need? And at what point does consistency come at the cost of good teaching? Well, today's guest is living this debate firsthand, and this episode was both unplanned and unhinged. I met Trista Matthews at the Cotsen Foundations annual conference in California, where she introduced me before my session, and within hours, we were recording this podcast. Trista has spent twenty-three years teaching elementary school, and she's now a mentor coach, helping other educators navigate some of the toughest challenges in teaching. Today, we're getting into the messy reality of what happens when curriculum expectations clash with the art of teaching. We're talking teacher autonomy, the pressure to follow the rules, and whether it's even possible to teach with fidelity when you're working with actual human beings. So if you're a teacher who's ever felt torn between doing what you're told and doing what you know is right for your students, trust me, you are going to feel seen in this episode.
Supporting teachers through coaching
Vanessa VakhariaOkay. Okay. Hi. Hi.
Trista MatthewsThank you for having me.
Vanessa VakhariaWelcome to the pod. Thank you. Okay. So what, who are you?
Trista MatthewsOkay, so
Vanessa VakhariaI love how you reacted so normally to that. Okay. Yeah, so I see that this is your... So just so you guys know, we have just met today. Yes. A matter of hours ago.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaBecause Trista introduced me today. Which was so nice, but when she introduced me, I realized we had to have you on the podcast. Yes. 'Cause I feel like there's more to the story, but I also don't know anything about you. So- Yes.
Trista MatthewsBecause it was divine intervention.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay, so let's hear about this please.
Trista MatthewsOkay. So my name is Trista. I am an teacher here in Southern California. Okay. Actually in Orange County. this is my 23rd year in elementary school, general education, public school. and Three years ago, I was introduced to the Cotsen Foundation, which is the conference that we're at today. Yeah. it's their annual conference. the Cotsen Foundation, very, just very quickly, is an amazing nonprofit organization who, gives back to teachers and supports teachers, in any way possibly they can. Mainly through offering, professional development, through amazing educators and consultants like yourself, and also through the coaching process. And so-
Vanessa VakhariaYou guys have like an intensive coaching process.
Trista MatthewsYes, we do. And so I, at my school site where I teach, was, asked to be the coach at my site.
Tamra MooreOkay.
Trista MatthewsSo I am currently the Cotsen mentor or Cotsen coach at my school site. and I have a group of six teachers that I work with at my school site. And so my job is to support them in the goals that they create, for their year. It can be a short-term goal, long-term goal. So we work together for two years. so I get to do this job for two years with the same six teachers.
Vanessa VakhariaThat is incredible.
Trista MatthewsAnd so if you know anything about working in public education and being a general education teacher, the one thing that us as teachers always want is time to, perfect our craft and support in order to do it. And so Cotsen offers those two things through professional development and coaching through a coach. And so-
Vanessa VakhariaWhich is unbelievable. Like, just even being here today, the vibe is, like, you know what? It's like the vibe is, like, hopeful. And I feel... Like, not that other teachers aren't hopeful, I just feel like it's so hard because we often go to professional development, and it's like you know you're having this inspiring day, but you know there's nothing after that.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaRight?
Trista MatthewsAnd so my job as a Cotsen mentor coach is to now sit down with my, we call them fellows. They're fellows in the program. So my teachers that I work with are my fellows, and we will sit and talk about our day today and talk about what are some things that really spoke to you? Is there anything that you wanna try out in the classroom? Like, for example, being in one of your sessions today, something that I know one of my teachers already spoke to me about was your exit ticket and keeping a receipt, and she's like, "I wanna try that." Yay. So on Monday, we are going to pull up that resource. We're gonna print some out, and we're gonna try in a classroom. And so my job is to support her in that. How can I keep her accountable in what she wants to do? And maybe even help her collect some data on it to see if it actually is changing a student's belief about who they are as a math- mathematician.
Keeping the receipts of student progress
Vanessa VakhariaWhat, how would you do that, by the way? Like, if you, for this particular thing, like, I'm just curious 'cause I'm like, oh, like, how would you pu- like, what kind of data would you collect?
Trista MatthewsYeah, so it's, the great thing about the Cotsen program is it's all about what the teacher needs from me. So the teacher is really driving their journey, Say, for example, one of their goals is, "I want my students to really, have a positive math identity. I want my students to see themselves as mathematicians, to see themselves as, successful and this is something I can do." What I would do then is what I feel like she's probably going to do, is have me collect data on these, and I'm just kind of throwing it, an idea out there. If they're doing these receipts, right, of, you call them positive-
Vanessa VakhariaWait, let's explain that. So it's like the idea of the receipt. Yeah. Tell me what you understood, then I can see if I explained it properly.
Trista MatthewsOkay. Okay. So what I understood is that we all have, like this self-fulfilling prophecy of like, if I think I'm a bad mathematician, if I think I'm not a good math person, then I'm going to find things that kind of fulfill that belief in me.
Vanessa VakhariaOh my God, you're going so deep, but that is so correct. yes, that's our brain's confirmation bias.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaWe wanna like confirm- So that confirmation bias like subconsciously we're like trying to confirm things we believe to be true.
Trista MatthewsExactly. So my negative self-talk is going to tell me things like, "I can't do that. That problem's too hard for me." and so what, what I took away is this is just like a concrete example of something you did well as a mathematician today. I took risks. I tried a problem and I, you know, didn't, like- Have an anxiety freak out about it, have a, have a meltdown.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Trista MatthewsI asked a question.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Trista MatthewsMaybe some kids just don't feel comfortable asking questions.
Vanessa VakhariaOr like, I showed up to class today.
Trista MatthewsExactly. And so like, what are... And I love that you had some already like pre-written ideas on there, like taking, I took a risk, I asked a question, like I solved a problem. Different things that you had on there. What I would do as, as a mentor, as a coach for my teacher, is we would sit down and say like, "What kind of data are you looking for?" And she'd probably say something like, "Well, I wanna see that my children's identity of themselves, identity as mathematicians, is really coming out in what they're doing in the classroom."
Vanessa VakhariaMm. So let's just to back up for everyone listening. So this is something I called keeping the receipt. Yes. So the i-
Trista MatthewsKeeping the receipt.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah. So the idea of the exit ticket is like at the end of every day, the exit ticket is a student has to write down something, like a win. Right? Like just something that was good. Literally anything. It could be like, "I showed up to class. I didn't have a- math meltdown." Like, "I helped somebody else. I understood something more than yesterday." Whatever it is.
Trista MatthewsYeah.
Vanessa VakhariaThen the idea is to turn in those receipts, and the teacher is collecting this data so that they have a pile from every student to be like, like-
Trista MatthewsNo, you did. Like-
Vanessa VakhariaYou look at all the stuff you've done, and we can decide what to do with that pile.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaBut now you're saying, "Oh, we could use that pile as data." And maybe the teacher's like, "I'm looking to see if them keeping those receipts actually affects the way they interact and perform in math class."
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsSo we can, I mean, it can be anything-
Vanessa VakhariaThen how do you do that? Yeah.
Trista MatthewsSo it can be anything from, just looking at how maybe class discussions are going. Maybe like it was, like a students weren't talking in math class. Right. Like she would ask a question, and it would be like silenc- silence. Like crickets, right? Well, maybe as we're collecting these, these exit tickets, keeping the receipt, and we start to notice that children or the students are saying like these positive things about themselves, or we as the teacher are reminding them, "Hey, like remember when you ask a question or you took a risk?" By us affirming them in that, is that changing the, how discussions happening in the classroom? We can take anecdotal data. We can even interview some students and, and say, how do you feel about yourself as a mathematician now?" Then maybe compare it to before we started, you know, um, taking this-
Vanessa VakhariaWell, and this is when you can combine strategies. So I don't know if you ever used, have you ever used like a math mindset survey?
Trista MatthewsYes. Where at the beginning of the year you kind of ask them how they feel about themselves as like a mathematician as a reader, as a writer.
Vanessa Vakhariain the show notes to a resource I made with a math, mindset survey that you can do that with for anyone who wants to do that. But that, that's a great way to combine resources, right? Because you could do that- then you could do something like the keep the receipts, and then you could measure the, you could do the math mindset survey, like a month or two after to see if things have changed.
Trista MatthewsYeah. And so, you know, and then once, if we start to see change in the classroom, I'm like, "Awesome." I, you know, I meet with my fellow, meet with my teacher, and usually what comes from that is, well, what can, how can we build on this? And then another goal might, you know, come from that first goal that we created. So that's really my job as a coach and mentor, at my school site to support my teachers.
Were Trista and Vanessa destined to meet?!
Vanessa VakhariaYou said... Wait, first of all, we haven't talked about the divine intervention thing.
Trista MatthewsYes, I know. I need to talk.
Vanessa VakhariaI know. I could tell. Right? You were probably like, "What is happening?" Yes. Don't worry, I'm tracking. I was like, hold on a second. Why is it di- divine intervention that we met?
Trista MatthewsYeah. Well,
Vanessa VakhariaI- Because I'm about to ask you a whole different question, I was like, no, we have to bring this back.
Trista MatthewsOkay. Well, be- so before you ask that question, I'll tell you about the divine intervention. Okay. So as another part of my job is to, find resources for my teachers. So say for example, they were thinking, "Oh, I really want to get students talking more in my class." Well, my job then as a mentor is to see if I can go and find resources for them. And you were a resource that I found.
Vanessa VakhariaHow? Why?
Trista MatthewsSo, I had a math fellow last year who was really struggling with, implementing what we call like these, the CGI strategies in her classroom.
Vanessa VakhariaCan you say more about what that means?
Trista MatthewsYes. So CGI strategies, CGI stands for cognitively guided instruction. Okay. and so it's really centering students and their thinking and what they bring into the math classroom, and building upon what they know. So what strategy did you use to solve that problem, and not saying like, "Hey, that's a wrong way." That's the way you solved it, honoring their thinking, and then building upon that knowledge in the classroom. Knowing that we were gonna be getting, like, a new math curriculum this year, our district was, uh, piloting a math curriculum last year.
Vanessa VakhariaWhich one was it?
Trista MatthewsUm, Eureka.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsYeah. So they were piloting, a few, they were piloting a few, but Eureka was one of them, and that's the one our district ended up choosing. She was, struggling with, "How can I implement what I know is good teaching with, what this curriculum is asking me to do?" So I just was doing my research, and I came across your podcast.
Vanessa VakhariaOh my God.
Trista MatthewsAnd-
Vanessa VakhariaThe podcast that we're on right now. Yeah. I love a full circle.
Trista MatthewsOkay, yeah. And, and I sent it to her, and I said, "You have to listen to this. This is amazing. what she's talking about is so relevant to what not just you
Vanessa VakhariaWhat was it?
Trista MatthewsAre going through.
Vanessa VakhariaLike, what were you even listening to?
Trista MatthewsSo it was, it was a podcast just on, I think it was, like, beginning of the year.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsIt wasn't the beginning of the year when I found it, but the very first podcast that I happened to listen to, it was about beginning of the year implementing, like, beginning of the year routines or i- But it wasn't specifically about the routines you were talking about. It was the bigger picture that you were talking about, like looking at kids in their full humanity and what they're bringing into the classroom, and really talking about math anxiety and traumas that us as teachers maybe have inflicted upon kids without knowing it, and how we can How can we fix, how can we fix it? And so it was just good teaching. And so I loved it so much, I loved your podcast so much-
Vanessa VakhariaOh, my God
Trista Matthewsthat I sent it to not just her but I sent it to all of my teachers because I felt like it wasn't just relevant to teachers of math, but it was relevant to all teachers. And so we just started listening to it. So we've been listening to you for, you know, the last year and, and here's where the divine intervention part comes in. So-
Vanessa VakhariaI love, I just want everyone to know- that we have Trista's friend- sitting in the wings, okay? And just, like, making the funniest comments. She just, like, it's like, it's like we really have our own audience here. Yes. But she seems to be very excited about the part that's about to come up- Yeah in the story.
Trista MatthewsSo hopefully it meets your expectations.
Vanessa VakhariaSo I just want you guys to know what the situation is over here.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaWe're gonna see if we can get her on. Yes. She says she doesn't like to speak publicly, but-
Trista MatthewsShe needs a couple more glasses of wine
Vanessa VakhariaShe, she does like to heckle the crowd. The, she likes to heckle the speaker, as it seems.
Trista MatthewsOkay. Okay. So, um,
When curriculum gets in the way of good teaching
Trista Matthewsright now our teachers are just in a really hard spot where they're really struggling with now we have this new curriculum and all of the demands that are getting put on teachers as to, how it should be taught to fidelity, and even having teachers be told, like, to throw out CGI, and we only have to teach the curriculum. And so they're just struggling, and so I felt like-
Vanessa VakhariaAnd can I- sorry, just to like, the struggle is here, this is something we've talked about on the podcast before- but just to be so clear for like a new listener who's like, "What is the problem? Just follow the curriculum. All good." Often the curriculum- the idea of teaching to fidelity means basically follow exactly, do not insert any of your own literal anything. Yes, yes. So like read the question, read the lesson as written. Yes. And if you're doing that and you in your mind know of some practices that you love, that are effective, you wanna bring in some CGI, you wanna bring in- some math therapy, you wanna throw in- Yes some building thinking, like whatever- Yes you're not supposed to do that. Yes. So all of the stuff you've learned as a teacher, an expert at your craft you're basically being asked to toss that out the window and just follow a script.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd that is a struggle often when the script is not aligned with what you know to be good teaching.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsAnd so the teacher who is struggling actually heard about Building Thinking Classrooms from you, from your podcast.
Vanessa VakhariaPeter?
Trista MatthewsLoves Peter. Are you listening? And is actually Tamra's, co-teacher. She teach- teaches sixth grade. Shout out to Kelly Calvert.
Vanessa VakhariaOh, my God.
Trista MatthewsUm, so Tamra teaches with Kelly and was like, "I love Building Thinking Classrooms. And they want me to do this curriculum, like to fidelity. And she because she listens to you now too, was like, "Trista, Vanessa just did this amazing podcast with, Chase? I forget his name.
Vanessa VakhariaWith Chase.
Trista MatthewsChase.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah. Okay. Yes. Okay, that makes sense
Trista MatthewsWith Chase. And she's like, "You have to listen to this." This was two weeks ago.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsAnd I know that podcast was, like, back in June, I think, June 18th.
Vanessa VakhariaIt was, yeah, it was, like, in, yeah, June.
Trista MatthewsBut then you just did in the beginning of September-
Vanessa VakhariaYes
Trista Matthewsthe one-
Vanessa VakhariaThe Middle Path.
Trista MatthewsYes, the Middle Path.
Vanessa VakhariaSo we did another episode unpacking that episode with Chase-
Trista MatthewsYes
Vanessa Vakhariawhere I did a live, kind of like this but in front of an audience.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaMe and Chase talked about curriculum stuff.
Trista MatthewsYes, you did.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd then I did, yeah. We'll put all the links to all of these in the show notes.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsSo Kelly was like, "You have to listen to this because, this is what we're living right now. Like, where do I find that middle ground? Where can I not get fired?" Yeah. Like, like he was talking about, like Chase was talking about, but still keep my job and stick to what I know is good- is good teaching. And so she sent it to me, and that was like two weeks ago. and it just touched me so greatly that I sent it again, like I do Vanessa's podcast link to all of the teachers that I know with me in my cohort at another school that we work with they listened to it. And so on Tuesday, just this last Tuesday, I had my monthly meeting with my group of teachers at my cohort, and of course that's what they wanted to talk about, like they're struggling with the new math curriculum. Just feeling the weight of not being able to, you know, teaching is an art, and not being able to show that in their classroom and be responsive to what their kids need. So I told them about your podcast, and I shared it with them, talked to them at how amazing you are and so much that I have learned about, math anxiety in the classroom and not wanting to cause further trauma to our students. And after that meeting was over, I go to my computer, and I have an email from Julie Graham, who's the director of Cotsen, and she is letting me know that I'm gonna be introducing someone at the conference on Saturday.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsAnd It's your name.
Vanessa VakhariaOh my God.
Trista MatthewsAnd I'm gonna start crying because I Literally, you have been in the topic of conversation for the last maybe the last year of my life as a fellow.
Vanessa VakhariaOh my gosh.
Trista MatthewsBut the last two weeks you've come up often. And so for me to go and sit in front of my computer after I just talked about this podcast and what it has done for me, and to know that first of all that you were gonna be at the conference, I started freaking out just knowing you were gonna be here. And then I get the email like, "Oh, you're gonna introduce her." And Julie has no idea about this connection that I've had with you over the last year.
Vanessa VakhariaThere are no coincidences. That's what I always say.
Trista MatthewsThere is not. Uh-huh. And I think we all have points in our career to where we question, like, "Am I doing what I'm supposed to be doing? Was I the right person chosen for this coaching position?" Yeah. and to see your name pop up, I think was just confirmation for me, like, "Trista, you're exactly where you're supposed to be, doing exactly what you're supposed to be doing," and advocating for these teachers and in turn advocating for students. And I was just so honored to be able to introduce you today-
Vanessa VakhariaOh my God
Trista Matthewsand to meet you. Yes.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd you did an amazing job. It was like the nicest-
Trista MatthewsOh, thank you
Vanessa Vakhariaintroduction ever. So much hype. that obviously means so much to me. And I feel like we're all, in this world and in this space- like, doing different parts of the work. Do you know what I mean? Like, it's like- you know, and, like, sure, I have a podcast and I'm, like, always, like, ranting and blabbing, but it really is an honor for, for me to even know that it's in, beyond it being entertaining- that it's in any way, like, helpful in terms of actually, like you said, like, honing your craft and feeling like you have, not permission because you don't need me to give you that, but, the... what's the word? Like, not motivation 'cause it's not that.
Trista MatthewsWell, it's like, it's an encouragement.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah, the encouragement to keep going.
Trista MatthewsAnd what you said about these bracelets, too, in your session is that a lot of times we stand in that room by ourselves.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Trista MatthewsYou know? We're in that room with stud- we're in with students, but we in a sense are alone in that we are the only teacher in that room. And so to know that I can look at this and say I have a community of math, not just math teachers, but of educators that are telling me, do what's right for kids. Like, be responsive to what's happening in front of you. And if that just means, like, I push off that curriculum lesson for the day because I have a student in front of me that, needs more support or that needs to be pushed, and that's not in my lesson for today, then, then that's what this reminds me of.
Vanessa VakhariaOh my God. Can you just come with me?
Trista MatthewsThat's what you're doing for
Vanessa VakhariaThat means so much
Trista Matthewsfor teachers. So thank you.
Vanessa Vakharia'Cause, I mean, I also feel... Thank you. That means so much. I mean, I often think that too. Like, I'm like- what am I doing? Or, like, yeah, is this... I think we all question that at different points in our lives. And I actually think that's really good in a way, because one thing, I'm, not in the session you went to, but the session before, I talk about our definitions of success and failure and how they should grow and change as we grow and change. And something we may have wanted and have achieved might no longer align with who we are.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaSo I actually think it's really, like, important to be reflective, and I think if you're questioning whether or not you're meant to be where you are, it doesn't mean you're not meant to be where you are. It means that you have the wherewithal to be reflective and to take a look around and to see the forest for the trees, and to just make sure... It's like a check-in, right? You wanna check in to be like, "Am I still doing what's aligned with me?" Yes. Great. But if you don't do that check-in, you just end up following the motions. Like, before you know it, you're like, "Oh my God, it's been 10 years and I'm doing this thing that doesn't align."
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd I mean, that, this kind of almost ties in in a way to, like, everything you're
Can teaching ever have fidelity?
Vanessa Vakhariasaying. I actually wanna ask you, since you're actually dealing with this, and you're dealing with educators who feel so frustrated by the, this curriculum conflict. It's kind of the same thing, right? If we just start following, if we just start being like, fine, we're following with fidelity, we're not, when we're not thinking, right? Like, when we're not using the free will that we have access to, we, we risk being out of alignment. That's right. And then we risk being frustrated and feeling like we're not fulfilling our purpose as educators. How, what's some advice do you have for educators who are feeling like, "I've gotta follow this curriculum with fidelity. I'm not allowed to bring any of myself to teaching." And I love how you said it, the art of teaching, the practice I've honed- is something I can no longer be creative with. What do you say? What do you do?
Trista MatthewsI think recently I've learned just the word fidelity. Can you really have fidelity in anything if it's-
Vanessa VakhariaLike,
Trista Matthewswhat does that even mean? Yeah, if it's being done by a human. Oh, wow. Like, if it's being done by a human, can you really have fidelity in it? Because as a human-
Vanessa VakhariaWhat's the definition of fidelity?
Tamra MooreOoh, wait. Yeah. I might be able to help.
Vanessa VakhariaWe got our fact checker over here. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Trista MatthewsBut,
Vanessa VakhariaI mean- Oh, glass of wine is almost empty.
Trista MatthewsYeah, yeah.
Vanessa VakhariaWe're all adults.
Trista MatthewsYou're asking a human being to present a curriculum to fidelity. But as a human, I'm bringing all of my lived experiences. I'm bringing everything that I am as a person. There's no way that that curriculum is gonna be presented with fidelity.
Vanessa VakhariaWhat does it mean? Tamra? Got the fact-checking. Okay. Fidelity means the quality of being faithful, loyal, or exact in reproducing an original.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay, this is making it even more fucked.
Trista MatthewsYeah. So to me it's like, do you want a robot? Because to me-
Vanessa VakhariaDo you Well, this is so funny, all the conversations that are anti-AI.
Trista MatthewsYes, exactly.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd now we're, oh my, okay, wait, so the exactness with which a copy, sound, picture, or translation matches the original. So you, oh, that makes sense, high fidelity- Yes in audio is, like, reproduces audio or images very closely to the live source. Okay, so hold on. This is a great point.
Trista MatthewsSo that completely takes art out of the picture.
Vanessa VakhariaWell, you can't.
Trista MatthewsLike, and humanity.
Vanessa VakhariaYou're a photocopier.
Trista MatthewsExactly. So I'm a human. Like, I can't do anything with fidelity- if I am bringing my whole self. And-
Vanessa VakhariaEven if you were bringing a little of yourself.
Trista MatthewsExactly. That's what I mean. So, so when I hear administrators or anybody, and even me, I mean, I'm guilty of it. Before I knew, like, I would be like, "Oh, my district said I have to do this to fidelity. That's what I need to do." But, like, I didn't even know what I was saying. Like, there's never anything that can be done with fidelity, if we're talking about a human connection and a human experience as teaching.
Vanessa VakhariaDrop the mic. Except do not touch your microphone. Okay. Okay, this is such Like, I don't know how I've not thought of this, but I have not thought of this before. Like- that is such a good point. So, so then I'm, like, kind of like, "Okay, hold on, so what the fuck are they wanting here?" Like, you, why hire, why even go to teacher's college?
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaYou could just hire, like, somebody to work an assembly line, essentially. Yes. 'Cause you just want them to read a script.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaBut so, so what is, what is the balance here? What's, like, a version of fidelity Well, first of all, I think we should stop saying that word.
Trista MatthewsYeah. Which it, you're right.
Vanessa VakhariaRight? Like-
Trista MatthewsYou're right
Vanessa VakhariaWhat are we meaning? Like, what should we mean? What's, what- what do you coach teachers to do? 'Cause it's like, okay, so they need to fo- Okay, I don't, I wanna stop using the word need. The, the call to action is to follow the curriculum.
Trista MatthewsYes. So if the call to action is to follow the curriculum, the way that I'm following th- the curriculum in my class might look very different from the way Tamra is following the curriculum in her class, depending on the students that are sitting in front of her. And so I still feel because it's, teaching is a human art form, I have to put some of myself in it, and I can follow a curriculum, but still be able to add my art to it.
Vanessa VakhariaMy friend Allison Mello always says, "The curriculum is the chicken-"
Trista MatthewsYes
Vanessa Vakhariabut we, like, bring the spice." So it's like you're still making chicken. Like, you're gonna- I heard that episode. I heard that podcast. Right? It's a good one. Whenever she And I was like, "Oh, my God, I really like that." I'm sorry.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaRight?
Trista MatthewsOr, like, someone might need, you were saying, you're still gonna have a salad.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah. Did I say that?
Trista MatthewsYou in, in the podcast that I heard- you, you were talking about salad.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay. Yeah, I do love a salad.
Trista MatthewsSome people might need Chinese chicken salad. Some people might need a Santa Fe chicken salad. Some pe- people might not be able to have chicken at all in their salad, but they're still gonna have the salad.
Vanessa VakhariaI don't think I said any of this. Did I?
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaOh, my God. I'm gonna go listen to this.
Trista MatthewsThis might have been, 'cause I like to listen to archived episodes.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah, this could've been. Like, old episodes. This could have happened. I love this. I love that you know me better than I know myself. Okay, so,
Why don't we trust teachers to teach?
Vanessa Vakhariaso this is interesting though because I'm also, like, just, like, thinking about this on a deeper level. I'm like, okay, so did this Is this new? Like, all of this, like, all of a sudden people really cracking... Did, has this always... 'Cause just so you know, by the way, I've mentioned this on previous episodes, but I'll say again. In Canada, we do not have curriculum.
Trista MatthewsYes, I've-
Vanessa VakhariaIn this way. Right? Like, we, we don't-
Trista MatthewsI have heard you say that.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah. Yeah. So we just, like, the, we're not standardized testing.
Trista MatthewsOr standardized testing.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah. When we use the word curriculum in Canada, we mean content.
Trista MatthewsOh, you mean content. That's right.
Vanessa VakhariaSo it's like what's in the curriculum? Adding fractions is in the curriculum. The Ontario curriculum has fractions in it, right? So you don't, and you, you go to teachers college, and then you go into the classroom, and there's worksheets and there's some ti- you can teach however you want. You just teach however you want.
Trista MatthewsSo you actually have an art of teaching.
Vanessa VakhariaYou have an... But what's funny is when I started learning about curriculum in America, I was like, "Oh, my God, that sounds so convenient." Like, in, in Ontario- Yes like, we, you gotta make all your own lesson plans, whatever.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaBut then I slowly realized it's a slippery slope.
Trista MatthewsYes,
Vanessa Vakhariait is. Because actually you're not allowed to do anything at all. You have to just follow this thing and become this robot.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd then it is an art, and most educators go into educating because they are creatives, they are healers. Yes. That's what we do. We are these social beings with empathy- Yes who care and care about the student.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd that is the complete opposite from being an actor who wants to read a script.
Trista MatthewsExactly. And so now I think you understand why so many educators feel unseen.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Trista MatthewsUnheard, unsupported, because truly their identity and wanting to care for the reason why they went into teaching on the first pla- in the first place is being taken from them.
Vanessa VakhariaThis is so crazy. So, can, is this new? Like, has it always been like this? I th-
Trista MatthewsIt goes in waves. Yeah. It goes in waves. Okay. It goes in waves, and I feel like With the pressure of standardized testing and scores, which goes back to funding and money, the pressure becomes more enduring those times of like "oh my gosh, we're not meeting our, you know, our growth target." and so this curriculum, everybody has to do it. That way, the district or the administration can say, "Well, we've done our part. Everybody has the same exact, like everybody's delivering the same lesson." "We're doing... So it can't be us."
Vanessa VakhariaI get it. I just had such an epiphany. That probably everyone else already knows, but I realize what's happening. Yes. I'm like, so basically it's like test scores are low, so the solution is let's standardize everything. Yes. So it's like, okay, fine. Test scores are low. Everyone just read this script.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaGet kids to do the exact same thing, and then everyone's on a, quote, unquote, "equal playing field." Yes. We know it doesn't work that way. Yes. But it's like, right, it's like, it's like we, we... Then exactly, we've done our part because- Yeah everyone's reading from the exact same book- Exactly and doing the exact same thing. But it's like such a misunderstanding of the problem. Cause like test scores are not low. I mean, because by that theory then, the theory is that test scores are low because there's variety in teaching.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd because some teachers are not teaching properly, let's say.
Trista MatthewsYes, that's correct.
Vanessa VakhariaBut the truth is test scores are low for so many other reasons. Some of those reasons, one of the major reasons being that we are teaching too homogeneously- That's right in the first place, and not every kid can learn the same way.
Trista MatthewsExactly.
Vanessa VakhariaAm I right? I'm just yelling at this. That,
Trista Matthewsno. Okay. That is correct. And you're exactly correct. Yeah.
Vanessa VakhariaSo the solution to that is what you guys are doing, in a way. Like, p- part of the solution.
Trista MatthewsYes. Yeah, yeah.
Vanessa VakhariaYes. Which is being able to teach the curriculum while pulling on these individual threads of what might work with your students.
Trista MatthewsExactly. Or having the freedom, which even some districts are not even allowed to have the freedom to say like, "Let me look at this curriculum and use it as a resource."
Vanessa VakhariaOh.
Trista MatthewsOr like, maybe I m- might wanna pull this lesson because this is something my, you know, this fraction lesson, my kids are really struggling. but you know, they're doing really well in, you know, associative property. And so I won't need, I don't need that lesson. But when it, when districts are asking you to do things in fidelity, it's like you're not being responsive to the kids that are in front of you and what they need. And so I think if teachers knew that they had the permission to be creative and pick and choose things that they know will work for the kids that are in front of them, That that is where I think we need to start. But unfortunately, that takes a district releasing control. Right? That means they have to be able to trust the teacher. They have to be able to trust the educator, that the educator's gonna make wise choices and do what's right for kids, and I think that's really hard for a district to do when- With the pressure with the pressure- Yeah of scores.
What can teachers actually do?
Vanessa VakhariaSo can you say something to the teacher right now who's listening, who's, like, yelling at this podcast being like- "that's me. I'm being told to follow the curriculum with fidelity. What the fuck do I do?" Yeah. "Like, tell me what to do." What's one thing you would say?
Trista MatthewsI would say, number one, make sure that you have a community of other teachers that are with you, that it's not something that you are doing by yourself but that you have a group of teachers that are going to be on the front lines with you and saying, "This is what we're gonna do together." And be an advocate for your students because, to me, how can you say no to what a teacher is doing when, like, if I had my principal come into my room and say, for example, I was supposed to be on lesson 15, you know, module two on that day, which is what a lot of districts are asking for, right, that we're all on the same lesson the same day. but she walks into my room, or he walks into my room, and sees students, not on that lesson. However, they are engaged in mathematical discourse. There's joy in the learning. They are asking questions about the mathematical practices that are happening in front of them. They're encouraging one another. Like, I don't see any principal or administrator walking into my classroom, seeing that, and saying, "Why aren't you on lesson 15, day th-" Like-
Vanessa VakhariaRight
Trista Matthewsso to me, it's the, the teaching that needs to speak for itself. If they're gonna trust us to do what we know is right for kids, then when they walk into our room, they have to see that happening.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Math Therapy beyond the math classroom
Vanessa VakhariaWell, this has been so amazing. Can I ask you if there's anything, just because this is kind of how we started, for, for teachers listening, are there any episodes of ours that you were like, "You need to listen to this one." Like, if you were gonna recommend one. Are there any Math Therapy things you think they should try? Like, tell me any of that before we end today.
Trista MatthewsSo-
Vanessa VakhariaLike, what has kind of moved the dial for you? I
Trista Matthewsthink-
Vanessa VakhariaJust 'cause I also wanna know I'm making a difference. Okay. Of course. This is kind of for my own validation, to be honest.
Trista MatthewsWell, of course, and I would love to affirm and validate you. I, because it's truly gonna come from a place from my heart. So when I started listening to your podcast, it was really for my teachers. Yeah. Like, what can I take from you that I can share with them? What I've learned is that anxiety is anxiety, and it can transfer- Not just to math, but to real world just life. And so a lot of things that you talk about in your podcast are not just specific to math, but living life. And I've even helped, like, when you talk about confirmation bias, like, that is so true in all identities of our lives- right? Not just in our math identity. Yeah. but even with my daughter, I have a 10-year-old who struggles, a lot with her, she doesn't like school. "I hate going to school, Mommy. I don't like it. I don't have friends. I'm not good at it." And so something that I learned fr- and I can't think of the title right now, but that I learned from your podcast really is, like, we need to, and even I think you mentioned it today, is take whatever those negative, that negative thoughts that are happening and replace them with something positive. So instead of when you come home, instead of telling me all of the bad things that happened in your day, let's start with two good things first- and then we can go to what, you know, you wanna tell me about. But that came from listening to you, listening to you talk about math and the trauma and anxiety that happens around math. So it's so transferable into our daily lives. I think that's number one. Number two, the podcast with Chase, and I think that's just because it's fresh in my mind, and then the follow-up that you did just recently in September because I think a lot of us struggle with that balance of- What we in, you know, the United States call curriculum and then doing what we know is right for kids and what really is good math teaching. So that is the one that I shared with all of my teachers, and, I had a group, another Cotsen mentor who does what I do but at a different school. She sat down all of their tea- and they all listened to it together. They listened to your podcast together as part of their meeting.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay, stop.
Trista MatthewsSo, like, they were like, "Oh my gosh, Trista, you sent us that, you sent us that link, and we listened to Vanessa, and we loved her," so they all came and saw you today, too. Because, um-
Vanessa VakhariaThank you for being my greatest hype woman ever.
Trista MatthewsI know.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay.
Trista MatthewsBut yeah that's what I can think of right now.
Vanessa VakhariaWell, thank you.
Trista MatthewsBut you're amazing.
Vanessa VakhariaYou're so amazing. I mean, just, I feel so lucky for the teachers that get to work with you.
Trista MatthewsOh, you're so kind. Thank you.
Vanessa VakhariaYou know? And, I mean- Right? Like, it just, it just, I mean, first of all, it's such a beautiful, I know this isn't, like, we're not here to, like, prop up, like, Cotsen Foundation. But it's, it's really cool to see a program that, um, c- like, values and understands that professional growth and any type of growth needs consistency and long-term. I mean, we we can always go to a one-and-done PD and be inspired, and change can come from that. So I'm not out here, I actually think, I think there's power in all, whatever we can access there's power, but what great power to be able to work with you- consistently over two years. And I'm so glad you found me.
Trista MatthewsI'm so glad I did, too.
Vanessa VakhariaAnd I'm glad to find
Q1
Vanessa VakhariaIntervention. Okay, the two final questions I ask everybody. You have 30 seconds to answer each one, but this isn't a timed test, so, like, whatever. But you ask everybody on your podcast.
Trista MatthewsYeah. So I think I know the questions.
Vanessa VakhariaOkay. But no, go ahead. Oh my gosh, every- Okay, so question number one, if someone was like, "Wow, you're so cool. Love it all," whatever, but, like, yeah, just, "I'm not a math person, so I'm never gonna be good at math," what would you say?
Trista MatthewsI would say, "What makes you think that?"
Vanessa VakhariaSomeone was at my session today. Ah. I love that. I love that. Thank you.
Trista MatthewsWhat experience in, in your life that have happened that make you think that you're not a math person?
Vanessa VakhariaLove it.
Trista MatthewsWhat makes you think that?
Vanessa VakhariaLove it. Love it. Fucking
Q2
Vanessa Vakharialove it. And finally, if there's one thing you could change about the way math is taught in schools, what would it be? You can pick one thing. A genie will grant you one wish.
Trista MatthewsOh my gosh, about the way math is taught in schools? I would probably say I feel like sometimes math is taught in isolation. It can be very, like, um-
Vanessa VakhariaSiloed?
Trista MatthewsYeah, siloed. And I would love to see us almost approach it as we do, like, a science. You know? Like, well, math is a science, but, like, how we would approach, like, a science lesson or a biology lesson or a chemistry lesson, where we really start with, like, more, like, that inquiry-based, and we're working collaboratively as a group to solve this problem.
Vanessa VakhariaI love that.
Trista MatthewsSo really less siloed and more working together as a team.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah, it's more-
Trista MatthewsAnd maybe even across... Like, I'm thinking of, like, 'cause I, I used to teach kindergarten and first grade, so I'm thinking of, like, how powerful would it be if my first graders got to go and, and work with Tamra's sixth graders. So really, like, look at that.
Vanessa VakhariaYes.
Trista MatthewsTeaching math that way.
Vanessa VakhariaYeah.
Trista MatthewsLike, what, how powerful would that be?
Vanessa VakhariaLike a team sport.
Trista MatthewsYes.
Vanessa VakhariaI love that. Um, I, thank you so-
Trista MatthewsYou are so welcome
Vanessa Vakhariamu- what a, like, what a random, sweet thing.
Trista MatthewsI know.
Vanessa VakhariaYou're also such a great pod- Like, she's so articulate. Like, you were just like- Well, thank you like, you really broke things down. I feel like I was really, like, grasping for words, and you just said everything so concisely and perfectly.
Trista MatthewsOh, well, thank you so much, Vanessa.
Outro
Vanessa VakhariaOkay, guys, how amazing is Trista? Like, first of all, can we just appreciate the fact that we met hours before recording this episode? Like, what are the chances? And I honestly cannot thank her enough for being so open and honest about what teachers are going through right now. One thing I keep coming back to from this conversation is something Trista said, "Teaching is a human art form." And I love that because isn't that what this whole debate really comes down to? We're trying to figure out how to give every student the education they deserve, while also recognizing that every student is different, every teacher is different, and learning is a human experience. And look, I know there are people listening who disagree with some of what we said today, and I genuinely wanna hear from you because I don't think this is a debate with one simple answer. But one thing I hope we can all agree on is that teachers deserve to feel trusted, supported, and empowered to do what's best for their students. So whether you're a teacher who's feeling completely shackled by your curriculum, or maybe you're someone who believes strongly in the importance of consistent instruction, I want to know what you think. So text us right now. You can do that using the link in the show notes, or come join the conversation in our Math Therapy Facebook Group. A huge, huge, huge thank you to Trista for this beautiful, completely unexpected conversation, and thank you for listening. And I just know there's someone in your life that came to mind while you listened to this episode, so share it with them right now. Math Therapy is hosted by me, Vanessa Vakharia, produced by David Kochberg, and the theme music is by our band, Goodnight Sunrise. All right, love you guys. See you next week.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Making Math Moments That Matter
Kyle Pearce & Jon Orr
Math Teacher Lounge
Bethany Lockhart Johnson and Dan Meyer
Math is Figure-Out-Able!
Pam Harris, Kim Montague
DebateMath Podcast
Chris Luzniak & Rob Baier
Math Chat
Mona Iehl